French Three Strikes Act seems to be successful
The so-called Three Strikes Act seems to be a successful tool in the battle against piracy. Several studies show that the appeal of piracy has reduced in France, due to the Three Strikes Act. Also the sales of digital entertainment products are growing in France. Furthermore, music industry revenues are starting to stabilize, according to The New York Times.
The French Three Strikes Act makes it possible to disconnect internet users if they engage in illegal file sharing, after they have received three notifications of violating copyrights by illegally downloading pirated content.
By the end of 2011, Hadopi, the agency that administers the three-strikes system, had sent 822.000 email warnings as First Strike to suspected offenders. These were followed by up to 68.000 second warnings. Of those 68.000 second warnings 165 received a third warning, whereby the French Courts are authorized to disconnect the internet users of the internet, and may impose fines of €1500,- up to or nearly €2000,-.
From this relatively low number of third-stage offenders, Éric Walter, secretary general of Hadopi, concludes that the French three-strikes system works properly. This statement seems to be supported by recent academic research. A study carried out by the American Wellesly College and Carnegie Mellon University reports that there is a causal link between the iTunes music sales and the Three Strikes Act. In 2010, research by Adermon and Liang led to the conclusion that stricter enforcement of intellectual property law in Sweden caused the amount of illegal downloads to decrease and the sales of authorized digital music to rise.
The President of France, Nicolas Sarkozy intends to strengthen enforcement powers of the Hadopi agency, by giving it more tools to crack down on unauthorized streaming and other forms of piracy. However, now the French presidential election is near, opposition to the Three Strikes policy is increasing. For example, opponents question the causal link between growing digital sales and the enforcement of the Three Strikes Act.
Read more about the French Three Strikes Act on FutureOfCopyright.com:
- Australia one step closer towards Three Strikes ?
- French Three Strikes : half a million warnings sent as first strike
- French Socialist Party against Three Strikes
Reference: The New York Times, Webwereld
By: Deniece Teterissa

Comments(3)
.
We should be talking about more than causal links. If you were to introduce the death penalty for stealing from supermarkets, there would be a causal link too... but at what cost?
phulshof
A rather one-sided view of the matter, IMHO. Webwereld did a lot better in that regard, by also linking to the debunking of this report:
http://webwereld.nl/analyse/109589/franse-overheid---three-strikes-wetgeving-werkt-.html
http://www.lemonde.fr/technologies/article/2012/01/24/hadopi-source-de-la-croissance-d-itunes_1633919_651865.html
http://torrentfreak.com/anti-piracy-no-effect-on-itunes-sales-120124/
Peter vd Veen
The two arguments above are indeed interesting points: everyone will agree that enforcement IPrights is justified, however the question is how strictly these enforcement measures should be applied in practice. It is good to see public debate on this issue. French 'three strikes' policy and its execution by Hadopi is effective, according to Hadopi. at the same time it is under fire in political discussion, especially with upcoming elections. Hopefully critical politicians in France will have sound alternatives in mind, to keep the discussion constructive. Furthermore I do believe that consumer demand (and sales) for legal content will increase once the illegal market is being curtailed or made less attractive.
Your comment